Friday, November 12, 2010

Football In The ACT Region Takes Another Kick in the Guts!

I could hardly believe what I was reading in the Canberra Times - The ACT Government had struck a deal with the as yet, non existent, AFL Club called Greater Western Sydney, to the tune of $26 million over a ten year period, adjusted for the CPI. The pay off is reported to be the grand total of four AFL (some Premiership standard) per season.

Wow, again bloody wow and thank you very much. I feel like I lost a thousand and found a cent. They are jumping for joy in AFL land in the ACT Region and laughing all the way to the bank in greater Western Sydney and AFL headquarters in Melbourne!

Just get yourself around the magnitude of the deal, courtesy of we ACT taxpayers - a cool $650,000 per game for ten years (adjusted for CPI, mustn't forget that !!!)


Now the Raiders and Brumbies get nothing like this sort of money, but they have done nicely over many ears, thankyou very much. Good luck to them I say.

So when is it pay day for Football in the ACT?

Questions:
  1. Did anyone on the Capital Football Board know this sort of money was in the wind?
  2. If they did, where is Football's share?
  3. If they did not, why not?
  4. If there is a plan to get $26 million dollars out of the ACT Government to develop the game in the ACT, what is it and when will it deliver?
Football has a playing constituency of more than 18,000 ACT citizens (all ages). The supporter base is so much larger and many are parents, bound to the sport because of their children's participation.

You  could wrap AFL, Rugby and Rugby League up together and not match Football participation rates.
This is real "sports political muscle", so why doesn't the Capital Football Board flex them and get Minister Barr's attention.

Where is the FFA and Frank Loewe when you need him?

I just get the uncomfortable feeling that the Capital Football (Board) has been asleep at the wheel on this one - probably more like comatose given the magnitude of the ACT Government investment. What are they scared of - that the ACT Government won't help them - well, have a look Football sportsfans, they didn't!

And please, don't accept any talk about the ACT Government's generosity toward Football through the Hawker enclosed redevelopment. Football paid part of that price, which is more than AFL will do in the ACT through Greater Western Sydney.

While we in Football have been walking around patting ourselves on the back over the installation of a terrific artificial surface at Hawker Enclosed, gratefully accepting crumbs Minister Barr's table at the ACT Government, AFL thought bigger and better, lobbied and got all they wanted. And the GWS AFL team doesn't even exist yet, nor will it base operations in the ACT.

We in Football in the ACT just don't think big! Or maybe we have the wrong people doing thinking for us! And remember, we are chasing our share of public funds here to assist the development of the game in our   region.

Another three Hawker enclosed type facilities,and we would have a plan wroth noticing, but not one that takes ten years to mature and for much less cost than $650,000 per game (adjusted for the CPI, must not forget that), then we would have something to praise, we woul dhave forward progress in the biggest (and best) game in the ACT (and the World). The ACT Government just does not take the Footaball community seriously. Why is that?

What really strikes me as plain nauseating, is that the Football sporting public is expected to be satisfied with a decision by the ACT Government to trade little more than four AFL games a year and the hint of an "Academy" and something about improving Manuka Oval (again!), in exchnage for $26 million smackers!This is the worst possible use of public funds in support of sport and does absolutely nothing for Football going forward.

We need an enormous boost in playing surfaces and facilities and not just for Football across the ACT. This is a scandalous waste of public funds.

Let's hear Capital Football on this one - loud and clear please!

This is a real kick in the guts for Football.

Read the Canberra Times article below:
Barr's $26m AFL punt

BY LEE GASKIN AND JOHN-PAUL MOLONEY

11 Nov, 2010 08:48 AM

The ACT Government will fork out up to $26 million of public money to bring a Sydney-based AFL club to Canberra over a decade.
In an unprecedented deal which blows the Government's contribution to Canberra-based professional football teams out of the water, Greater Western Sydney will play 40 games, 30 of those premiership fixtures, in Canberra once the club enters the AFL in 2012.
The Government's funding comprises an annual $1.15 million partnership payment to GWS from 2012-13, plus an annual revenue guarantee of $1.2 million, or $400,000 for each of three premiership games. The Government says the total annual figure it will pay is $2.35 million.
This will increase annually by the Consumer Price Index (CPI), or by 2.5 per cent, whichever is smaller. When the deal expires in 2021, the total sum paid to the expansion club could reach $26 million.
However, the Government hopes future improvements to Manuka Oval will enable an increase of the venue's earning capacity and let it recoup some of that expense.
The annual level of funding is much more than what the Government pays to the ACT Brumbies and the Canberra Raiders. The Brumbies receive about $1.7 million per year and the Raiders about $1.8 million. They both play more than triple the number of matches in Canberra than GWS will.
Reigning WNBL champions the Canberra Capitals are believed to receive just under $200,000 per year.
Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation Andrew Barr admitted he was braced for a backlash from Canberrans who believed the money could be better spent elsewhere.
''There are always going to be people who don't like any government investment in elite sport, and they'll be some who don't like the code,'' Mr Barr said.''That's inevitable.''

16 comments:

  1. Once again… Capital Football demonstrate their level of commitment and amateurism! Same old… same old, PATHETIC!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I worry that we in the Football community look like we come cheap! To the ACT Government, to the FFA and to the A League Clubs!
    Good luck to the other sports (Brumbies, Raiders and now the AFL through GWS)- they got what we want.
    Again, the question - with Football's world profile, hosting a World Cup in prospect and a huge particpation rate locally and nationwide - how did we fail to secure public funding to the same level as an AFL team in Western Sydney?
    This question must be answered.
    What is Football's and Futsal's propects in the ACT region going forward, because from where I stand each week on the sidelines, I feel we are condemned to endless chook raffles and BBQ's which just prise a little bit more form the dedicated fans. We will never get enough on our own.
    I was reminded by a colleague in Football and Futsal yesterday that it is highly likely that the top three tourist participationa ctivities (and income earners for ACT based business) are:
    1. Floriade
    2. Kanga Cup
    3. FFA Futsal Nationals

    That's two Football related activites int he top three.

    The same person also pointed out to me that what we need for Football and Futsal int he ACt is a "Football Mega Faciltity" that would cover off Football, Futsal, HPP, have room to expand (Hawker does not!!!) and be the focal point for this sport in our region. Ironically, something like the one in Western Sydney. It could be used for sports other than Football and Futsal.

    We could do an emormous amount fr football and futsal for a lot less than $26 million. The $26 million of public funds we have just gifted the AFL through GWS, leaves nothing behind for any sport, except the litter that fills the garbage cans at Manuka oval (though of course they will be "upgraded" garbage cans).
    Make sense of that if you can, because I can't.

    Get vocal with Capital Football (email the Board, they are the ones that need to be put on notice)if this lost opportunity troubles you. Let Minister Barr know the Football community has been treated badly and it will not be forgotten till it is put right.

    Please don;t criticise the AFL, they just got what we desparetly needed and they did it so much better.

    Think Football (and futsal) and get mobilised. If you don;t speak, others conclude you don't care and that's not good enough for our football community and the many young players now and to come.

    ReplyDelete
  3. its like beating a dead horse,
    and you dont listen,
    you dont see the afl to worried about womens afl,
    thats why they get 26 million
    i think its too late for canberra, unless there is a major overhaul.
    btw great crowd at the first united game

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Heather

    There is more to football in the ACT than Canberra United...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good thing Heather Reide did do soemthing about womens's football in the ACT Region. But remember, its not big money and our players don;t earn a living wage while they are undertakeing a full professional footballer's wrokload (and study, keep jobs etc). And its still a work in progress.

    In this respect the CEO Captial Football has done outstanding work.

    How the Capital Football Board seem to have missed the boat for Football's share of $26 millions is beyond me. If they have lobbied and secured something substantial then let us know the detials and many of us will stops thinking that they appear to have been asleep at the wheel! (remember, the ACT Gov writes the first cheque for $650,00 to GWS, at the latest, following the completion of the game in the ACT by GWS next season).

    ReplyDelete
  6. On the subject of beating dead horses.
    Maybe we get what we deserve if we don't stand up and tell Capital Football (and through our CLubs and Zone Reps)that they are not doing enough and being seemingly outwitted by AFL for vital ACt Taxpayers dollars for the biggest game in town and the world, is s grevious error of judgement.
    Tell them, don't give up.
    Get a ticket togethre for the next AGM, attend the AGM and vote in those you think will bring the change needed for football int eh ACT region.
    It was a good crowd for the CU game,, but we need more!

    ReplyDelete
  7. wake up and smell the roses everybody literally...
    the only ones who care are those with high performance kids and they are generally too afraid of speaking up for fear of retribution on their kids...
    the last hope lies in the Ron Smith review and FFA to step in and clean the place out and start from scratch...
    do you think that's going to happen?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Now that's a bit harsh and a bit off the mark on this subject - ie the $26 million that went East to AFL and not a sheckle for Football or Futsal int eh ACT!

    Ron Smith is a sensational football coach and analyst. He will produce a report that will illuminate a lot of corners in our football environment. His report should be distributed to the Football community for comment. Who will sign off on the way ahead - The Capital Football Board.

    Now we are back to money, resources, faciltities and so on. Need them going forward to make the game work at every level - not just HPP. If community football is in strife, then no amount of attentnion to HPP will save the game from mediocrity. That's the signifcance of the lost opportunity in a $26 million expenditure on sport and none of it for football. Simple really.

    Your comment about parents being afriad to speak up because they do not wish their children to be adversely affected, is, I am saddened to say, a familiar private reflection among many parents I have spoken to over the years. No amount of money can fix this one, this is all about how people treat each other, how honest they are in all their dealings with each other, how reasonable parents are with their expectations and how good the Capital Football HPP training really is in every age / gender group.

    ReplyDelete
  9. "How the Capital Football Board seem to have missed the boat for Football's share of $26 millions is beyond me."

    Peter - Football has no 'right' to that money. There was no 'share' of the $26m.

    The ACT Government put money forward for the A-League bid that fell through.

    This type of uninformed journslism helps nobody. If there had been a pot out there you can be assured that football would have applied for some.

    Football's 'share' is supplied by support for the Kanga Cup, Futsal nationals, Junior national, Canberra United, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is deligthful piece of obfuscation.
    Yes there was $26 million on offer and the AFL did well to get it. Capital Football missed it. The ACT Government offered considerably less for the A league For Canberra bid, a lot less in fact and ended up paying nothing because the bid failed. That's nothing for football in the ACT, I repeat, nothing!
    And now your last sentance - just how much do you think the ACt government speands per annum on the Kanga Cup and Futsal nationals? I understand they are major net revenue earners for business in Canberra. And about the National Youth Championships in the ACT (assume that's what you mean)- parents of players pay most and the rest of the tab should be picked up by the FFA. It wouldn't happen if parents didn;t pay. The NAtional Training Centre Challenge held at the AIS involves a very small number of ACT players and again it and FFA event.
    Canberra United - who pays? We do, the ACT Football constituency and good thing we do, it well worth the money and only possible because we don;t pay the players a living wage (nor does anyone else). Hopw much do you reckon the ACT Government kicks in for Canberra United - peanuts!
    Sir or Madam, you are woefully misinformed.
    The deafening slience by Capital Football (and hear I mean the Board)says it all. They should howling the roof down. What are they scared of, upsetting the Minister? Really, haven't you and they noticed - a wedge of wonga went East never to return.
    A lot of money for sport int he ACT just went to a minority sport in this region and for next to nothing in return. The largest participation sport in the ACT region has never enjoyed that sort of ACT government patronage and its about time it did.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Peter, I can assure you I am more informed than you are. I KNOW for a fact what money the ACT Government provides for the Kanga Cup, The National Futsal Championships, the Junior National Championships and Canberra United, down to the last cent. I don't need to guess.

    And I can doubly assure you that there was no part of the $26 million available to football. If, and when, we get an A-League team across the line the money will be available from the ACT Government.

    I suggest you direct your 'rant' at the ACT Government before publicising misinformed facts that seem just another way to cast doubt on Capital Football. If there was money in a pot for local sport don't you think cricket, netball, hockey, rowing et al. would all have been 'howling the roof down'?

    How's that for a 'deligthful piece of obfuscation'. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  12. You are still obfuscating, that's for sure.
    How about you give us some facts. Better still, emial me and we'll do an interview for the NPL.
    The question you seem to aviod is why was no part of the $26 million available to football.
    If you read carefully you willnote that must unhappiness is given in equal measure to Capital Football and the ACT Government.
    Let's agree to differ.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 'The question you seem to aviod is why was no part of the $26 million available to football.'

    That's a question you'll have to ask Andrew Barr mate. You've just confirmed the point I was making. Football didn't miss the boat, it wasn't offered a ride in the first place!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you. And why was it not on offer? There are two parties hear that need to give an account of themselves - ACT Government (Mr Barr) and Capital Football. Mr Barr has side stepped direct explanation and CF has said nothing.
    Perhaps you are suggesting that the ACT Government had / has no intention of assisting Football to the same extent as AFL, and if you are, it requires explanantion. That brings us back to Capital Football.
    Let's leave it at that see if Capital Football can make a run at this one and tell us what they have done.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Peter, perhaps you should ask Capital Football? I'd imagien you'll get the same response as written above. There was no money for football so how can Capital Football be held to account for something that they had no control over. Just another swipe at the governing body again it seems. It's apparent you hold some sort of grudge or agenda against CF.

    And how about the $45 million the government made available for the World Cup bid? It's for a 'special purpose' it's not for a general 'let's dip into this' pot.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I did! Not the same answer at all. If there was money for Sport, whether directly through the "sports" budget or the Chief Minister's contingency funding or the Tourism budget, then there was money for Football. There was always money for Football, we just didn;t get in front of this and secure it. Did Capital Football do enough - no. Did the FFA for Capital Football, the A league bid and with teh ACT Government - most definately not.
    Do I hold some sort of grudge against CAPital Football - no. Listen to my interviews with CapitaL Football.
    Is Capital Football or the Board above criticism or questioning - no.
    The World Cup bid funding is large and that's the sort ofmoney you neeed to expend to go forward. Its an obscene waste of public funds and always spent by Government (Federal or state) on the basis that they advancing the country commercial "brand". Such a waste, yes a waste in absolute terms because no one Australian child or youth player get a return from this expenditure, at a time we here in the ACT are sreaming out for a pathway for our young talented players. The opoortunity cost of a decision to expend funds (no matter where they come from or what account bucket they are located in) is enormous. We gambled in a rigged game, then claimed we were honest brokers - well I don't doubt we were, but surely we knew what was against us and if we did we wasted our money. This was ego and arrogance operating, not good sense and we need more than this in Football, particularly as our domestic senior Leagues exist on the mragin. Maddness. Worse than this - this sort of money is on the low side of bid expenditure, in a FIFA process that is profoundly corrupt. Why, the consult we hired has made it abundantly clear that we lost because we didn'y play the "corrupt" game. We should never have played if this was the only way to play. Concentrate on qualifying to attend and we go there anyway.
    I'm not talking about dipping into this pot - please follow the thread.

    ReplyDelete